Stainless, non-stick or cast iron

Stainless steel pans on an induction hob
Base construction decides everything. Brand decides very little.

Three materials, three different jobs. Most kitchens need two of them, and almost nobody needs a fourteen-piece set.

Stainless steel

The workhorse. It browns properly, takes any heat, tolerates metal utensils, goes in the oven and lasts decades.

The thing that matters is not the steel — it is the base. Steel conducts heat poorly on its own, so good pans sandwich an aluminium or copper disc between steel layers. A thin single-ply pan will scorch in the centre and stay cold at the edge, whatever it costs.

Check the base is at least 4–5 mm and that the cladding runs up the sides rather than stopping at the disc.

Non-stick

Right for eggs, fish and pancakes, and wrong for almost everything else. It cannot brown properly, because browning needs the food to stick briefly.

Treat it as a consumable. Even careful use gives you three to five years:

  • Never above medium heat — high heat degrades the coating
  • Never metal utensils
  • Never a dishwasher, whatever the label says
  • Never heat it empty

Once it is scratched or food starts catching, replace it. A worn non-stick pan is neither non-stick nor pleasant to cook on.

Cast iron

Enormous heat retention, so it sears better than anything else and holds temperature when cold food hits it. Also heavy, slow to warm, and it needs seasoning and drying rather than soaking.

One skillet is worth owning. A full set is not.

A sensible kit

PieceMaterialWhat it does
20 cm saucepanStainlessSauces, grains, small quantities
24 cm saucepanStainlessVegetables, pasta, stock
28 cm sauté panStainlessBrowning, one-pan dishes
24 cm frying panNon-stickEggs, fish, pancakes
26 cm skilletCast ironSearing, oven finishing

Five pieces cover essentially all domestic cooking. Large sets pad the count with lids and small pans that live at the back of the cupboard.

Induction

If your hob is induction, the pan must be magnetic. Test with a fridge magnet: if it grips the base firmly, the pan works. Stainless usually does, aluminium and copper usually do not unless a steel plate has been bonded on.

← Back to Guides

Ask us about this
Scroll to Top